top of page

Is your hire fixing a recruitment problem, or something else?

Oct 27
3 min read

Is your hiring fixing a recruitment problem - or something else?

How many times have I heard some version of this?

“We need one more person.”

“We need a specialist.”

“We need someone more senior.”

“We need someone who has done this before.”

And then recruitment starts, because once the decision has been made that another person is the answer, the next steps feel fairly straightforward: write the job description, get the salary approved, go to market and start looking for the person who will hopefully make the problem disappear.

Sometimes, adding headcount is exactly what is needed. Sometimes, it isn’t.


Hiring is an easy lever to pull

When a team is struggling, recruitment is often one of the first solutions people reach for because it is tangible, visible and relatively easy to turn into action, while understanding why the team is struggling in the first place can take considerably more time and may lead to answers that are less comfortable.


  • Is the business model strong enough?

  • Are the processes efficient?

  • Are we getting enough from the tools we already have?

  • Do people understand what is expected of them?

  • Are employees motivated and rewarded in ways that support the work?

  • Are we setting and managing client expectations well?


Those questions require more than opening a requisition. They require someone to stop, look at how the team operates, challenge a few assumptions and sometimes accept that the missing ingredient is not another employee.

Hiring, by comparison, can feel wonderfully concrete. There is a role to define, a candidate to find and an action everyone can see moving forward.

Then comes the shopping list

Once we have decided to hire, the expectations can start growing very quickly.

We need someone senior, but still hands-on; strategic, but happy to execute; able to build processes, improve performance, train the team, bring clients, know the industry and ideally start producing results very quickly because everyone else is already stretched.

None of those expectations sounds unreasonable on its own, which is probably why they accumulate so easily.

The problem is that by the time they all land in the same job description, we may no longer be hiring someone to do a job. We may be expecting one person to compensate for weaknesses in the business around the job.

And that is where it becomes worth asking whether this is still a headcount problem, or whether an operational, management, commercial or process issue has gradually been turned into a recruitment brief.

What is this person expected to fix?

This is why I encourage internal recruiters to go further than “What are you looking for?” during an intake meeting and spend some time understanding what the new hire is expected to change once they arrive.

What will this person allow the team to do that it cannot do today? What are they expected to fix? What happens if we do not hire them? And is there any part of the problem that could be addressed internally before we assume another employee is the answer?

Maybe responsibilities need to be redistributed, maybe a process needs fixing, maybe the current team needs clearer expectations, better training or more support, or maybe the technology is already there and the business is not getting enough from it.

There are also plenty of situations where hiring is exactly the right answer.

The workload may have outgrown the team. A capability may be missing. The business may be entering a new market, launching a new service or reaching a stage where a different level of experience is needed. Sometimes there are not enough people to do the work, and no amount of process improvement will create the missing capacity.

That is fine.

The point is not to talk ourselves out of hiring. It is to understand why we are hiring before we start looking.

Because once that is clear, the role itself usually becomes clearer too.

A new hire enters the system you already have

Recruitment can bring capacity, expertise, judgement, experience and knowledge that the team does not currently have, but the person you hire will still enter the organisation as it exists today.


  • If the processes are unclear, they inherit them.

  • If priorities constantly change, they will work around them.

  • If client expectations are unrealistic, those expectations will still be there after the person joins.

  • If the manager has no time to manage, adding another direct report does not create more management time.


And if one role has become the answer to five different business problems, there is a fair chance the person will eventually be judged on whether they managed to solve all five.

That is a heavy job description for anyone.

So before adding another name to the org chart, there is one question I think is worth spending a little more time on:

What problem are we trying to solve?

Sometimes, the answer is recruitment.

Sometimes, recruitment is just the quickest lever available.

Comments


bottom of page